3C1+Group+A

Hi Gretchen! I was thinking we could each pick a cartoon to compare and contrast. I like the cartoon titled "Where both platforms agree." Let me know which one you like and then I'll get started on a rough draft. Emily

Hi Emily! I loke "Hoodwinked." I'll start my rough draft and post it when I'm done. Then we can chat about combining our ideas. Thanks!

GM

Hey Emily~ Here is what I have so far. What do you think? I'm not 100% sure I am doing in right, but here it is anyway. Thanks! GM

Hi Gretchen, The computer I am currently using does not have microsoft word...mine isn't working right and I'm borrowing my mom's laptop. Shoot, I'll have to look at yours tomorrow during school. Hmm...I can do mine through pdf, let me know if you're able to view it. Either tomorrow night or Saturday I can use my sister's laptop to see changes you make to yours. No biggie, I'll get it done one way or the other:) Emily

Hi Gretchen, Again, I haven't looked at yours yet and I'm not quite sure if I'm doing this right. I had to do some research into this topic, I haven't studied it since High School really. I found a website that listed the 2 men in the Platform cartoon as James Garfield and Winfield S. Hancock. []. Here is what I have so far though.

Hello again...I tried to open my venn diagram at work today and nothing was saved to it. I just realized tonight that on my mom's laptop that I am borrowing, her adobe version is old and won't save anything to the original copy. Thus, I am going to have to type up my comments here on the wiki. We have to turn in one final copy anyways. Do you mind having to type the final copy? I have no access to a computer with Word on it this weekend. I'm so sorry. It's such a mess! I realized tonight that the work I submitted for 3-A-1 was never saved and now I'll have to re-do it. Anyways, here are my comparisons: Hoodwinked: - Chang-Yen-Moon (consul in San Fransico) appears to be blindfolding Uncle Sam as Cleveland and Bayard do nothing. Cartoon depicts the Chinese as succeeding in trying to control diplomacy between China and the U.S. - Cartoon is coloful. - Printed in "The WASP" on Jan. 20, 1888

Where Both Platforms Agree: - Printed in "Pluck" on July 14, 1880 - Depicts the treatment of Chinese by //both// political parties. Title suggests it's the only thing the two parties agree on. - Chinese man and the cartoon in general has an almost sinister feel; it's in black and white.

Both: - Portray tensions between the U.S. and the Chinese immigrants. - Both exaggerate the Chinese men's physical appearance to some extent.

Here is our FINAL VENN DIAGRAM: